Bagel Shops We’ve Visted

Bagel Shop City County Would we go back? Favorites
Bob’s Bagels Lyndhurst Bergen y
Hot Bagels Fair Lawn Bergen n
Hot Bagels Teaneck Bergen y
World Bagel Cafe Ridgewood Bergen y
Bagel Cafe & Pizza Willingboro Burlington n
Bordentown Bagel Bordentown Burlington y
Beyond the Bagel Montclair Essex n
Hot Bagels Abroad Bloomfield Essex y
Sonny’s Bagels Inc South Orange Essex y *
Bagel Buffet Secaucus Hudson y
Hot Bagels Hoboken Hudson y
M&J Hot Bagels North Bergen Hudson n
Bagel Nosh and Deli West Windsor Mercer n
Bagels ‘n Cream Robbinsville Mercer y *
Bagels and Beyond Yardville Mercer y
Brooklyn Bagel & Deli East Windsor Mercer n
Central Perk & Bagel Company Hamilton Mercer n
Deli On A Bagel Cafe Pennington Mercer n
Hightstown Hot Bagels Hightstown Mercer n
Jim’s Bagel Loft Robbinsville Mercer n
Maidenhead Bagel Company Lawrenceville Mercer y *
Pennington Bagel Experience Pennington Mercer y
The Bagel Hole Princeton Junction Mercer y
Tina’s Bagel Factory Trenton Mercer y
Udo’s Bagels Lawrenceville Mercer y
World Bagels West Windsor Mercer n
Bagel Nosh and Deli New Brunswick Middlesex n
Bagel Pantry South Plainfield Middlesex
Bagel Street Grill Plainsboro Middlesex y
Bagel Talk Old Bridge Middlesex n
Bagels-4-U Metuchen Middlesex y *
Cranbury Bagel Barn Cranbury Middlesex y
Dee’s Bagel Cafe Monroe Middlesex n
Dunellen Bagel Dunellen Middlesex y
Golden Bagels Old Bridge Middlesex n
Hole In The Wall Bagels New Brunswick Middlesex n
La Bagel Edison Middlesex n
Milltown Bagels Milltown Middlesex n
Ruthie’s Bagel Dish Highland Park Middlesex y
The Bagel Place Plainsboro Middlesex n
Bagel Hut Aberdeen Monmouth y *
Bagel Oven Red Bank Monmouth y *
Bagel Station Red Bank Monmouth n
Bagelmasters Shrewsbury Monmouth n
Hole Lotta Bagels Middletown Monmouth n
JT’s Bagel Hut Forked River Monmouth y *
Stonebridge Bagels & Deli Allentown Monmouth y
Terrace Bagels & Cafe Freehold Monmouth y
Bagel Express Randolph Morris
Bagel Express Randolph Morris n
Mountain lakes bagels Mountain Lakes Morris y
Pop’s Bagel Shop Wharton Morris
Time For A Bagel Morris Plains Morris y
Pop’s Bagel Shop Wharton Morris y *
Bagel Barn Montgomery Somerset y *
Bagels-4-U Hillsborough Somerset y
Bagels-4-U Lamington Somerset y
O’ Bagel Basking Ridge Somerset y
Zee Best Bagels Franklin Somerset n
Bagel Chateau Westfield Union n


  1. Best bagels in NJ:
    Muheisen’s Bagel & Deli
    29 State Route 31 S
    Washington, NJ 07882
    Phone number (908) 689-6100
    Try them, they are in Warren County.

  2. You guys have to check out bagels and beyond in manahawkin in ocean acres its the best

  3. Go to bagelwich in verona, nj, best bagels in the state

  4. Ryan Durr · ·

    KC Bagel on RT. 23 in Wayne or Pompton Plains (right on the border) and Bagels Unlimited in Little Falls NJ

  5. lindsay · ·

    Bagels International, Bradley Beach, NJ is a must try!

  6. D.Bezak · ·

    You should try the Morristown Deli and Restaurant. They are on elm street in Morristown. It is known that they are known for their bagels and smoked fish. You guys gotta go. You won’t be disappointed!!!

  7. Russ Johnson · ·

    Must try bagel express in Randolph. Not pretty but great bagels.


  9. I have been to the majority of bagel places on this list. Try Bagel Loops in Wayne and Teaneck Hot Bagels. Among the best on my list.

  10. You need to go to Bagel Pantry in Metuchen! The Best Bagels Ever!!

  11. Frank Morelli · ·

    The best by far. Broadway Bagel at 2119 Whitesville Road, Toms River. Just a few feet off of Route 70. Worth the trip.

  12. Jennifer · ·

    Need to visit bagelissimo cafe , mansfield nj .. rte 206 near columbus market

  13. Robert Doherty · ·

    Broadway Giant Bagel
    2119 Whitesville road
    Toms River 08755

%d bloggers like this: